Sunday, November 3, 2013

Another Subpar WotW Performance: 93.2 at WotW

-Morro Bay
-In an incredible letdown for Feast Fest chefs, another subpar performance at Windows on the Water here in Morro Bay has manifested itself, as they will know have to go into Feast Fest with a goal of 99 or higher--having managed a measly 93.2 here at WotW.

It was a jump up from the 90.9 at Edelyn Cooking Arena in Punta Gorda, but, for the past seven years, the score at the chefs' final exhibition has fallen within 1.0 of their Feast Fest score for that year, meaning that, should that pattern hold up, the chefs would look at a score in the 94s on Thanksgiving--and they haven't let the score go that low since 2003.

Acting Head Chef Jim McAllister was numb.  "I just don't know what to say.  I really don't.  We came in here today with the right mindset, we knew what we had to do, but we squandered it--again."  WotW has typically been a house of horrors for the Feast Fest chefs; they usually average below 95 here.  In 2012, they managed 94.4, and in 2011 garnered 87.4.

But it was clear that McAllister wanted to focus on not what had gone wrong but what needed to be done to make up the difference.  He said that this exhibition had completely changed his outlook on FF 2013.  "I'll be happy to get back up into the 98s now," he said weakly, having previously extolled the chefs' best chances ever at reaching their golden goal of 100.  (The chefs had wipeout exhibitions in Boston and Tokyo in July and August, averaging scores of 98.6 and 99.4, respectively.  The 99.4 mark was their highest exhibitional score ever.)  "We don't know why we're slipping late in the offseason.  We're supposed to get better the closer we get to the Big Day.  I can't speak for what might be going on here."

The turkey score was a fair 95.1, so it wasn't dried birds that doomed this exhibition (though they were noted to be slightly parched).  Rather, vegetables seemed, mysteriously, to all garner low scores.  Peas had 91.0, green beans 88.3, and sweet potatoes 91.2.  Critics seemed to complain that they were stale and limp; one critic wrote that the green beans were "devoid of freshness and the cool snap needed to indicate said freshness."  All three of the aforementioned vegetables were provided by Feast Fest's official culinary provider for crops, L.A. Wild.  It wasn't the first time L.A. Wild had troubled peas, however.  In Feast Fest 2010, the peas had to be redone in the middle of the event.

Mashed potatoes was the top claimer, with a 99.2 score, but its phenomenal mark was not enough to save the overall score.

Lynn Avi had 36 points, the third most, in another somewhat tepid performance from the top chefs, though she was coming off of pregnancy.

The top claimer and subsequent MVC was D.A. Cook, with 52 points.  Cook received his first MVC since a 2007 exhibition.  (He has never received the honor during a full Feast Fest on Thanksgiving.)  Cook said he was "thrilled" to have received the MVC, but said that "we are all going to have to work hard to salvage this lower-than-hoped-for score on Thanksgiving."

Chefs will gather in Marina del Rey on Mon., Nov. 18, for a ten-day preparation session prior to Feast Fest on Thurs., Nov. 28.  "That will be extremely crucial," Lisa Choi (25 points) said.

Finishing off the leaderboard, Jim McAllister had 44 points, Jon Chu 35, Jarolde James 30, Patrick Kermell 22, Wiley Anders 22, Pete Willis 22, Ivan Peterman 20, and Lakeland Donavert 19.

FF Wire Service

Expert Analysis: Overcoming WOTW's House of Horrors In Final Exhibition Will Set a Vital Tone

Expert Commentator MIKE VILSHIRE
from Morro Bay, Calif.

-Don't believe the smiles on the faces of Feast Fest chefs in October 2012, when the 2013 exhibition schedule was released.

Their real train of thought? "Closing?! In MORRO?!?!?"

Morro Bay is a wonderful seaside village on the Central Coast of California, and Windows on the Water is a beautiful, award-winning culinary institution. Yet, it's hallowed halls have continually proved to be a house of horrors for Feast Fest chefs, who have scored below 95,0 there on five out of seven visits, including the disastrous trip in 2011, wherein a water main broke--twice--and led to the exhibition being delayed nearly 36 hours.

"I love coming to Morro Bay," Jan Stephan will tell you, "but WotW? We've never done well there."

It's puzzling. WotW has a large and well-equipped kitchen with a variety of innovative cooking technologies. While a bit more cramped than the expansive Edelyn Cooking Arena, it is the same size as the kitchen in Joe Pasik's bistro, Nø, and bigger than the tiny kitchen in Jim McAllister's Notes, both of which also regularly host Feast Fest exhibitions.

"We need to wipe out our negative mindset about WotW," Lynn Avi said Sunday. "We just have to come in and do our job." Avi seems to be the most ardent adherent to my theory: that a few bad times at Morro have led to the expectation that the chefs are ALWAYS in for a bad ride, which leads them to foul up and make mistakes. In 2010, 2011, and 2012, dry turkeys plagued the exhibitions and plummeted its score. This year, the moistness of the turkeys was "checked and re-checked" before the 5 p.m. start.

And a mechanical check confirmed that ALL cooking stations were in proper and working order, after complaints in 2008, 2009, and 2012 that they malfunctioned repeatedly.

So perhaps the concern surrounding WotW is just a bad case of culinary performance-based hypochondria?

One thing is certain: We're about to find out.

FF Wire Service

Cooking Bell Rings

-Morro Bay, Calif.
-We're cookin' in Morro.

The official cooking start bell rang at 5:12 p.m. Pacific Standard Time. The exhibition here at Windows on the Water, the final before the big dance on Thanksgiving Day, is expected to end around 9 p.m. With 61 of 67 chefs present, it is the highest-chef-attended exhibition of the year.

Lisa Choi got the style points going with some flame-y talents as she began to prepare her famous "pumpkins flambé."

89 turkey meals will be made, and, of those 89, only 16 will be consumed. The other 73 will be donated to local homeless shelters and soup kitchens.

FF Wire Service

Minutes Away in Morro Bay

-Morro Bay, Calif.
-With 61 chefs present, the final exhibition before Feast Fest on Nov. 28 is mere minutes away. The Windows on the Water exhibition here in Morro Bay is slated to have the Official Cooking Start Bell ring at 5:10 p.m. Pacific Standard Time, with about 150 in attendance.

The chefs will look to rebound after a subpar 90.9 finish at Edelyn Cooking Arena in Punta Gorda, Fla., on Monday.

"It's very, VERY important for us to crank out a solid performance in the final exhibition of the year so that we can go into Feast Fest feeling good about ourselves. It would've been disastrous if that had been our final exhibition." Edelyn usually is the final exhibition of the year before Thanksgiving, but, for 2013

FF Wire Service